r2i forum

[quote=Bobus;93872]Some beliefs are rational - the two aint mutually exclusive. What is the alternative hypothesis? That these are output of leg? Which foundations of Science are shallow?[/quote] If we need to have a logical discussion on the topic of “mind”, our opinions should not be admitted here ...

[quote=sandeepskar;93846]Thanks, Roger. I have already talked about science, the gaps/questions etc. in my post. I know there are gaps in Science abd I ahve said so that there are areas under investigation. That, however, does not automatically mean that the doubters right and any thought ...

[quote=sandeepskar;93780]The fact that mysteries exist that have not yet been explained by science does not make the entire field of science collapse. I can give you some more mysteries that science cannot explain, if you want. If a scientific theory is not able to explain something, then it can be ...

[quote=Desi;93773]Roger,

I think I will have some time later tonight and might respond tonight to your posts, else tomorrow.[/quote]

No problem, please take your time. I appreciate your taking time to share your thoughts for this.

[quote=Desi;93360]On the other hand, there are involuntary activities that humans engage in that may appear voluntary and these are result of damage to brain.[/quote] I agree here as this has been proved without doubt by experiments as to how electro-chemical changes as well as parts of damaged ...

Desi, There are many good lines you have written. Due to paucity of time, I will point to those lines alone where I beg to seek your further clarification. [quote=Desi;93357]Brain has other functions other than just being a collection of processes that form the mind. Some of the other functions of ...

[quote=neesha;93346]Now my question is, is brain the only vehicle of the mind ? or does it get one or more things done without involving the brain ? Of course, there may not be any scientific evidence for it and I don't even need one. Just wanted to know if anyone has observed this in the mind ...

Sandeepskar, [quote=sandeepskar;93339]True. But it is also true that we do not have any tangible proof that mind does exist after physical death.[/quote] I am not claiming anything here, but please keep in mind that there are unsolved mysteries involving reincarnation, near death experience, ESP ...

Sandeepskar, That was a balanced post. Please allow me to jump into only those lines where I differ a little. [quote=sandeepskar;93324]That is because, as Desi mentioned, if there is no brain then there is no mind.[/quote] If the brain is dead then all that it proves is cessation of activities of ...

Ignoring the blare you make, I state again that your admission below seems sufficient for an open discussion. If you have anything to substantiate on ?mind ? brain? theories that alone would be good to discuss further. Thank you [quote=Bobus;93311][I][FONT=&quot]Yes, there are lot of things about ...