r2i forum

I think its always a sign of tolerance when one does not imitate immature and bad actions. If some fundamentals carry out despicable actions, they might get some response from their followers ,perhaps but none from anyone else. And because they react in that manner, it is no benchmark that we should recede to their level either. I think hindus are doing just fine in being tolerant

Intolerance doesn't stem from any religion but from ones (lack of) understanding of what a religion preaches.

seeking;590236I read on Facebook

Magazine mocks Islam = 12 Killed, Movie mocks Hinduism = Rs 500 Crore Business

I merely want to discuss the point of tolerance on the part of Hindus. Whether PK is a good movie or a bad movie, whether or not PK actually insults Hinduism is not on my agenda. I am merely using it as an example.

If such a movie were to treat Islam in a similar way, what will the supporters of secularism in India say?

I do not mean to suggest that Hindus should take lessons from this incident and follow this path.

A muslim leader in India says every Indian is born muslim! Really? It is meant to be provocative but I am surprised at the muted reaction from those it is meant to provoke. In a way I am gratified that we don't the bait..

I think you are confused. Take a trip to Haridwar, bathe in Ganga and chill a bit. Will give you a perspective of what is Hinduism and why this way of life has survived for thousands of years.

seeking;590236
I do not mean to suggest that Hindus should take lessons from this incident and follow this path.

Great......

Human beings should learn what's worth learning from others......and leave the rest.....attitudes will help people self-distruct.
OTOH
If....Intolerance toward pluralism is what we want to learn from others........LORD Vishnu save us.....:-)

seeking;590236
A muslim leader in India says every Indian is born muslim! Really?

And what some idiot says really matters....because ?

seeking;590236In a way I am gratified that we don't the bait..

That says a lot about U.
Lets hope as society we act with inteligence and not as a crazy mad mindless mob.

seeking;590236.

If such a movie were to treat Islam in a similar way, what will the supporters of secularism in India say?

Don't know what anyone whould say....don't want to guess.
And what seculars ( like that idiot above ) would say...matters.....because ?

seeking;590236

A muslim leader in India says every Indian is born muslim! Really? It is meant to be provocative but I am surprised at the muted reaction from those it is meant to provoke.

Not really. Every Indian is a Hindu. This is already declared long before this guy said this.

layman;590258Not really. Every Indian is a Hindu. This is already declared long before this guy said this.

Violence is a sign of backwardness.
Reacting to what people say is also a sign of lack of self awareness or lack of self worth.

I am an atheist, but I am proud of most aspects of Hinduism. Btw, Hinduism is not a religion as such, it's a way of life, this is my understanding, correct me if I am wrong?

Another thing, what people/babas/orgs preach may not necessarily be what Hinduism represents.

One of the best aspect if Hinduism is: its not a organized religion, everyone is free to practice as they like.

seeking;590236I read on Facebook

Magazine mocks Islam = 12 Killed, Movie mocks Hinduism = Rs 500 Crore Business

......

I do not mean to suggest that Hindus should take lessons from this incident and follow this path.

Clearly, Hindus should make more movies which mock Hinduism. It makes more business sense. More money --- good for the coutry good for the economy. Heck 500 crore could mean 50 NRIs R2Iing!! I do hope we take lessons from this incident and follow this path.

I hope our new PM will start a new initiative of making more such movies.

seeking;590236
A muslim leader in India says every Indian is born muslim! Really? It is meant to be provocative but I am surprised at the muted reaction from those it is meant to provoke. In a way I am gratified that we don't the bait..

He is just borrowing the idea from Hindu leaders, -- since every Indian is a Hindu!!

techynt;590260....

One of the best aspect if Hinduism is: its not a organized religion, everyone is free to practice as they like.

Then it should not be an issue if someone wants to practice as a Muslim, Sikh or a Christian.

Why do Hindu leaders get upset with the conversions to Christianity? They really are going against the Hindu ideology then??

Hadith says every child is born upon Fitrah. Fitrah means natural disposition.