Cars: Innova vs Scorpio vs Xylo vs Safari vs Tavera

[hvn2hm]

Do these opinions still hold true for 2010 models?

From all of the useful discussion in this thread (a BIG THANKS to everyone), I am looking to buy a 2010 Xylo. Please post any positive and especially negative experience with 2010 Xylo.

[anuma]

I have also compared these cars. I was quite keen on Scorpio earlier, wife is/has been pro-Toyota. But seems we are veering towards Xylo - seems to be a good value-for-money car. Here's my spreadsheet:
http://www.r2iclubforums.com/forums/attachment.php?attachmentid=2576&d=1281360876 (looks like you need to be logged in to retrieve the spreadsheet)

However, I have heard from people in India saying that Xylo does not have good resale value.

[rmandy]

Does Maruti small cars come with automatic transmission?

I have researched but could not get any exact info.

Thanks in advance.

[hvn2hm]

anuma,
The link to the attachment is not working, says "Invalid attachment specified" when you click the hyperlink. I am logged in. Could you please repost the link? Thanks in advance.

I have also compared these cars. I was quite keen on Scorpio earlier, wife is/has been pro-Toyota. But seems we are veering towards Xylo - seems to be a good value-for-money car. Here's my spreadsheet:
http://www.r2iclubforums.com/forums/attachment.php?attachmentid=2576&d=1281360876 (looks like you need to be logged in to retrieve the spreadsheet)

However, I have heard from people in India saying that Xylo does not have good resale value.

[anuma]

anuma,
The link to the attachment is not working, says "Invalid attachment specified" when you click the hyperlink. I am logged in. Could you please repost the link? Thanks in advance.

Not sure why the link does not work, it is posted as an attachment to my blog entry.

You could try this link: http://cid-49aa2681ecabe315.office.live.com/self.aspx/.Public/cars-compare-IN.xls

[hydcat]

Don't know about Maruti but I-10(Hyundai) has an automatic transmission model but the mileage is low(8 to 10 km/L on local roads in Hyd).

Does Maruti small cars come with automatic transmission?

I have researched but could not get any exact info.

Thanks in advance.

[Matrix]

Does Maruti small cars come with automatic transmission?

I have researched but could not get any exact info.

Thanks in advance.

Wagon R comes with AT. But the wait period is 4-6 months.
Very few suzuki dealers agree to deliver a car with AT.

The gear box of Wagon R - AT does not look sturdy.

I10 or I20 is better option in small car segment if you want auto transmission.
I drive Santro AT. The wait period was supposed to be 1.5 month. I did not get the car on time.
After making a scene the dealer gave a car that was ready. However it was not the car that I ordered.